Cis Ally’s Guide To Not Being Transphobic
I claim absolutely no authority on this topic, these words and views here are based on the words of trans and non-binary people themselves, and my values. I’m a cis woman – not by choice, not by virtue, and not by default. It just happened that way. I have a fuckton of privilege for various reasons, and the least I can do is use it to shout for a better world. One in which trans and nonbinary people are loved and accepted the way we cis people regard as our due. TRANS RIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS.
I want to thank my fabulous friend Quinn Rhodes (site features NSFW content) for all hir blog posts on gender identity that have helped me learn, and for kindly agreeing to give me feedback on this post before I published it.
As I say, I’m cis and this advice is aimed at cis people because we’re the ones who really need to sort ourselves the fuck out, ally up and take a stand. Trans and non-binary people have been asking us not to make their lives so difficult for ages, but we keep allowing a wheel of excuses and demands for explanation, evidence, justification to spin on. Sometimes we screw up without realising it.
Most of us don’t want to think of ourselves as ‘transphobic’ – we might even bristle at the idea – but we’re human, so there’s a big gap between who we perceive ourselves to be and who others experience us. It’s easy enough to sign a petition, to retweet, to share a blog post (yes, I’m aware of the irony here) but our allyship needs to be more than our voices; our support has to be in our interactions too.
A Cis Ally’s Guide To Not Being Transphobic, Even By Accident.
1. Forget everything you have ever been taught about sex and gender, at school, through the media, by your elders. As a society, we have barely scratched the surface of sex and gender science – but we do have shitloads of empirical evidence that treating people with respect is better for everyone. The lived experience of other people stretches out behind you, unseen. What you think you ‘know’ is a tiny fraction of what is known and what has been.
2. Educate yourself. Read the words of trans and non-binary people themselves, starting with this excellent and accessible piece by Quenby (site features NSFW content). Read content from scientists, activists and allies. Look at your assumptions for what they truly are – habit and familiarity. Question them all, tear down the illusions and learn afresh.
3. A trans person’s deadname* is none of your business. End of. Don’t question them about it, don’t try and guess it, and if you know it, don’t mention it without explicit permission from that person.
(*the name that was assigned to a trans person before they transitioned. If you don’t know a person’s preferred name, then ASK!)
4. Don’t tell a trans or non-binary person how to feel or behave or speak about their gender identity. DON’T.
Seriously. It’s rude. It’s very, very rude. You’re the one who needs to catch up. Your opinions and discomfort are your learning opportunity, not someone else’s burden.
5. Ask questions respectfully and do not demand a response.
It’s wearying to have to keep justifying yourself over and over and over to well-meaning but ignorant randos. No-one owes you answers – in fact, no-one owes you their attention at all, no matter what demographic intersections anyone has.
6. When you encounter unfamiliar pronoun uses, or gender concepts that seem strange remember; those are only unfamiliar to you. This is a you problem, and it’s on you to update your thinking. The good news is that repetition ingrains familiarity, and familiarity is how we define ‘normal’. Your brain can adapt, as long as your attitude leads the way. Sit and think about it when you catch your ingrained biases going “huh?”. If you think about it often enough, the dissonance will fade away.
7. Apologise when you fuck up, and leave the words “but”, “however”, or “nonetheless” out of it. This isn’t a courtroom, or a TV debate. It’s life, and if you hurt someone with a mistake then you should feel bad and want to do better (no matter how excusable you may feel your mistake was). They absolutely do not have to absolve you and you shouldn’t ask.
8. Sit with your discomfort when you experience a trans or non-binary person’s anger, or fear, or deeply cynical weariness. Welcome to their world. It’s natural to feel cross and righteously indignant when someone lumps you in with horrible bigots, but that doesn’t make it right to hit back, or use your own anger to fuel prejudice (including your own). Just accept that you’re never going to get along with absolutely everybody out there and withdraw gracefully. GRACEFULLY. That means no parting barbs. It’s hard, it feels like giving in and backing down and admitting culpability even if you didn’t do anything wrong. But being supportive includes giving people space and taking your defensiveness somewhere else. Preferably into therapy*.
Being angry does not give you license to behave like a bigot, and being lazy, or ignorant, or rhetorical don’t either. That means always, ‘respecting folks’ pronouns, using the name they tell you to use and not asking what their ‘legal’ name is and/or what’s in their pants’ (thanks again to Quinn for the quote)
*I’m saying this in an encouraging and non-disparaging tone because I think most people could benefit from professional therapy, as long as they can find and access the right therapist.
9. Be fucking civil, goddammit. Gender identity can never be as deeply personal and emotive a topic for a cis person as for a trans person. Respect that their feelings on the topic are valid, even if you don’t understand them. Be polite, even when you’re feeling under attack. Don’t escalate.
10. Recognise when to STFU. Which I shall do shortly.
Of course, I’m not perfect and I don’t always live up to my own standards. I’m human, after all. I’d really like to be better though, which is why I wrote this post as a reminder to myself. I hope it’s useful to others also.
Thanks for reading
10 thoughts on “Cis Ally’s Guide To Not Being Transphobic”
Such useful, succinct guidance. Thanks to you both
Thanks for reading! X
This all feels and comes across rather like a preacher. At the end of the day treat everyone with the same common decency, and surly we wont have a problem. However, giving everyone a guide to not being a bigot is condescending at best and out right authoritarian at best. It is a harsh world out there and we all have to be nice to one another this kind of post dose not help anyone who isn’t already part of your flock.
You’re erroneously assuming that your definition of ‘common decency’ is the same as everyone else’s. If you know all this already, then great; I’m not addressing it to you so there’s no need to be so defensive.
Unfortunately, this post was written in response to recent events because people are NOT behaving with ‘common decency’.
I don’t know who you think my ‘flock’ is, but it doesn’t include bigots or arseholes, or people who refuse to examine their ideas.
Authoritarian. Lol. Saying to people “here is some advice on not causing unfair and unwarranted harm to others” and you think that’s authoritarian. You either need a dictionary or a clue, I’m not sure which.
The problem with treating everyone with the same common decency is it fails to take into account the unique experiences of individuals. We are all a product of our own experiences. Those experiences shape us and our worldview, they help us learn, grow, and in some cases, shrink.
Our experiences are often limited, so much so that we can struggle to see the influences of culture, upbringing, social norms and similar factors in molding our behaviours and our words. Those influences are the reason why two otherwise well-meaning people can come to diametrically opposed viewpoints on what is ‘right’.
It’s hardly authoritarian to write some advice for people who wish to learn more and to be better. It’s an aid; an opportunity to reconsider some of the things we accept, and to try and understand something that for most of us is very difficult to understand. I don’t have the experiences of trans people – I’ve never questioned my gender, and because of that, I will gladly admit that I lack the first-hand to experience to truly understand what it’s like to be trans.
Furthermore, I acknowledge I am fallible. I fuck up. I don’t mean to be ignorant, but on many subjects, I damn well am ignorant.
If you didn’t find the above post to be useful, if it doesn’t give you any guidance, if it doesn’t give you cause to think then great, I’ll assume you’re already much more well-versed than I am and have reached a level of understanding that I do not. But I’m still on my journey, and reminders, nudges, and just the occasional, ‘hey, remember not to’ actually helps untrain some of my own learned behaviours to hopefully not cause any undue hurt to a person I mean absolutely no harm.
Thank you for sharing this.
Thanks for reading c
Comments are closed.